Banks aren’t just for keeping your pennies safe!
First off, some bank light basics: Unlike umbrellas, bank lights are bulky (even when collapsed!), a pain to set-up, and equally frustrating to break down! But if your studio is a small room (like that spare, back bedroom) or your subject is highly reflective they are in a class by themselves.
Bank lights come in a huge variety of sizes to create beautiful, soft, directional light suitable for a huge variety of subjects. They are available as hard-sided light boxes or soft-sided collapsible units. Before manufactured bank lights were available every studio pro figured out a way to make one--from aluminum frames and Foamcore board. Big ones, small ones, rectangular, square and octagonal ones, they come in just about every size you might need!
Here are a 30x40-inch rectangular Chimera bank (this particular one is distributed by Dynalite) and a 19-inch octagonal Norman bank. There are banks that are also larger, smaller and even in between these two examples. The Chimera is designed to work with AC-powered flash units; the Norman fits on battery-powered flash units with removable round reflectors, such as those made by Norman, Lumedyne, Quantum, and Sunpak.
Adding panes to the movable window
Which looks better? Here are two photos of a blue glass bottle. One was made with a taped bank light and the other with an umbrella. Which photograph do you find more appealing? Which photo looks more finished and professional? Also note the difference in the background tone between the two light sources: The photo on the right is a perfect example of the extra spill light that's created when using umbrellas.
But is it Even?
To get the front panel of a bank evenly illuminated, many well-designed units have a second diffusion panel inside the bank, halfway between the light source and the bank’s translucent front surface. One way to discover if your bank light is even is to shoot a picture of the bank’s front surface and underexpose it by two or three f-stops. The underexposed photo will reveal any hot spot. If you’re shooting dark, reflective subjects and want a smooth, evenly-illuminated catchlight, you’re better off using a bank light with a secondary, internal diffuser included in the design. Look at these photos to see the difference a secondary, inner diffuser makes.
Here is my Chimera bank with and without the secondary diffuser in place. Note how the diffuser smoothes out the hot spots and makes the bank’s surface more even.
Break the Rule and Turn That Hot Spot to Your Advantage
Bank Light Impersonators
For your diffuser you can use Rosco’s Tough Rolux stapled to a single piece of 1x2-inch wood, or even create a frame made from four 1x2s held together with inexpensive angles from the hardware store to stretch the diffusion material across. You might even choose a piece of 1/8- or 1/4-inch translucent white acrylic instead but neither of these solutions is easily portable. Because I often work on location, and the portability factor is important to me, my favorite substitute for a bank light is a Flex Fill diffuser clipped to a light stand with a point source shining through it. Since I always have an extra light stand, 2 spring clips and a Flex Fill with me on location, I can simulate a bank any time I want one.
A Flex Fill, light stand and two spring clamps can do a pretty good impersonation of bank light quality if the catchlight shape isn’t your primary concern.
Impersonator #2: The Umbrella Masquerading as a Bank
There are some caveats here, though. First off, there can be a problem with the color of the light coming through the umbrella. As umbrellas age, the material yellows and, although a shift to the warm side is usually acceptable when photographing people, the results can be disconcerting when a technically exact color rendition is required. This is a problem with almost all diffusers made from white material so don’t get overly hung up on it. Secondly, if you don’t use some type of barn doors, spill off the edge of your umbrella can create lower contrast than when using an opaque sided bank light. See photo #8 to get the idea of how this works.
Ah ha….the old turn the umbrella around trick! If you use a translucent umbrella (or remove the black cover from a Photek one) it too can be a pretty good representation of a bank light. But, as in the above impersonation, it only works in situations where the catchlight shape is not paramount.
Whether you use an umbrella or bank there is one last point that is true about all broad light sources. To be most effective at creating tiny shadows they should be placed as close as possible to your subject. A 2 foot square bank light (or a 2 foot diameter umbrella) placed 50 feet from your subject will create the same type of large, inky black shadows a point source light at closer distances would! To illustrate this point we need only to look at the sun. Knowledgeable photographers treat direct sunlight as a point source light. In reality, our sun is almost a million miles in diameter (870,000 miles in diameter to be more exact) but, because it is about 93 million miles away from the earth, it creates the same type of large, inky black shadows that a 2x3 inch light creates when placed 5 feet from a subject. So, to paraphrase Al Pacino in Godfather Part 2, keep your friends close and your broad sources even closer!